I’m no economist, but the recent jaw flapping by the two Democratic candidates against free trade, i.e. NAFTA, is ridiculous. Free trade is not bad for our economy. In fact, economist squarely agree that free trade is good for the economy, and quotes by the chief economist, Ben Bernanke, extolling free trade are easy to find by putting “bernanke free trade” into a google search. Here are some selected quotes from his 2004 speech at Duke University:
One proposition commands almost unanimous assent within the economics community. That proposition is that free trade among nations promotes economic prosperity.
Trade creates jobs in the United States by expanding the potential market for U.S. goods and services.
Moreover, the savings that consumers enjoy because of the availability of lower-cost imports effectively increase household purchasing power, extra income that can be spent on other goods and services, including those produced domestically.
In the long run, avoiding economic isolationism and maintaining economic dynamism will pay big dividends for everybody.
To be sure, free trade does displace some workers, and this is a tragic shame. But the actual number of displaced workers is drastically over hyped. Another quote from Bernanke’s 2004 speech:
Only slightly more than 2 percent of gross job losses are the result of import competition.An analysis by Goldman-Sachs (2003) estimated that U.S producers shifted between 300,000 and 500,000 jobs abroad during the past three years, an average of between 100,000 and 167,000 jobs per year since 2000.
The unsexy and difficult solution to this problem is to help these displaced workers find new jobs. M.E. Markes from Forbes magazine had this to say in Why Do They Say these Things?:
It is equally true that free trade will always create winners and losers. And we should be paying far more attention to the disruptions in the lives of the losers, rather than railing against the free trade agreements themselves.
Closing our borders would destroy our economy. Does anyone remember the Cold War? Arguably, the collapse of the USSR was caused by a sluggish protectionist economy that drug living conditions, morale, and Socialism down with it. Russia is still living with these economic sins.
So, back to Clinton-Obama, come on guys! Get real! Barack, you’re smart, you went to Harvard, and Hillary, your husband signed NAFTA. You guys know that free-trade isn’t evil. You are just pandering for votes and offering false hope to the poor folks effected by the depressed Ohio economy. R. Karlgaard in Stand Up, Free-Trade Democrats! on the Forbes Blog had this to say:
Silicon Valley Democrats are free traders.
Smoot Hawley-style protectionism would be a disaster, a cancer. Free-trade Democrats need to see this.
And this too say in Trade Protectionism In the iPod Era:
One of the great threats to the American and global economies is trade protectionism.
I hope politically progressive CEOs like Steve Jobs step up and stop the protectionist drift of their party.
Democrats — Karlgaard and I are speaking to you! Don’t let your bleeding hearts destroy our economy.